Nitrate Destroyer: the model

The numbers behind the nitrate destroyer build, fitted to this tank’s own test log rather than to textbook constants. The page is regenerated from the log, last on 15 Nov 2026. Every figure on it is either a test or derived from tests; the assumptions are listed at the end.

Feed flowCarbonNitrite leaving the bedRemovedTank productionSettles at
29 mL/min21 mL/day0.4% (was 11%)1.75 ppm/day1.38 ppm/day (1.18–1.60)~27 ppm at 29 mL/min

Is the last step finished?

Outlet nitrite, as a share of the nitrogen coming in. It is the one reactor figure that has been measurable the whole time. Labels are the vinegar dose in mL/day.

0%4%8%12%30 Oct3 Nov7 Nov11 Nov15 Nov13.616171920210.4%
Five one-millilitre carbon steps from 16 to 20 left nitrite at 5–9% of the load. It fell to 0.4% two days after the step to 21. An iron trial and simply more time coincide with that step, so this chart cannot separate the causes.

Tank nitrate: tests, fit and three plans

The tank is modelled as one well-mixed 750 L volume: dN/dt = P − Q/V × (N − outlet), with the measured flow and the outlet nitrogen from each test. Only the tank’s own nitrate production P is fitted. Dashed lines run forward with carbon kept on the dose rule below.

0102030401 Oct15 Oct29 Oct12 Nov26 Nov10 Dec24 Declast test27 hold 29 mL/min23 35 mL/min16 +4 every 4 days to 52
Dots are tests, corrected for tank nitrite. Fitted P = 1.38 ppm/day; the fit stays within about 2 ppm of every test, inside the Hanna kit’s ±3–4 ppm.
TestMeasured, ppmModel, ppm
31 Oct37.436.2
6 Nov32.333.9
9 Nov31.633.0
14 Nov33.331.4

Dose rule

The carbon that matches the load: the oxygen in the feed plus all incoming nitrate down to nitrogen gas, leaving about 2 ppm at the outlet. Electrons per day = flow × (O₂/8 + 5 × (N − 2)/62) mmol; 8% vinegar carries 10.67 mmol per mL, and only a share of it goes to respiration, the rest into new biofilm. That share is fitted: 64%, on 15 Nov (21 mL/day, outlet nitrate 1.75 ppm, nitrite 0.1 mg/L).

01020304050510152025303540tank nitrate, ppm -> vinegar 8%, mL/day29 mL/min35 mL/min45 mL/min52 mL/min
At a fixed flow, carbon comes down as the tank’s nitrate falls. Every flow step needs more carbon, because more water brings more oxygen and more nitrate. The dot is the current dose.

Where nitrate settles

With the bed stripping almost everything it is fed, removal is set by how much tank water passes through it. The tank levels off where removal equals production: 2 + P × 750 / daily flow. Carbon cannot lower that level; flow can.

010203040502530354045505560feed flow, mL/minsettles, ppmcarbon now, mL/daynow
About 27 ppm at 29 mL/min, 23 at 35 and 16 at the 52 mL/min design flow. The band is the production range.

Every reactor test

Test (UTC)Carbon, mL/dayTank NO₃Outlet NO₂Outlet NO₃Nitrite shareRemoved, ppm/day
2026-10-30 12:0013.637.53–10.8%1.87*
2026-10-31 18:3213.637.42.25–8.1%1.92*
2026-11-01 09:121636.93–11.0%1.83*
2026-11-01 18:051636.52.25–8.3%1.87*
2026-11-02 05:501636.12.25–8.4%1.84*
2026-11-02 17:081635.62.25–8.5%1.82*
2026-11-03 17:041634.71.5–5.8%1.82*
2026-11-04 17:001633.81.5–6.0%1.77*
2026-11-05 14:061733.02.25–9.2%1.67*
2026-11-05 19:481732.82.25–9.2%1.66*
2026-11-07 07:471932.12.25–9.5%1.62*
2026-11-07 16:201932.02.25–9.5%1.61*
2026-11-10 18:522032.01.75–7.4%1.65*
2026-11-11 21:182032.41.75–7.3%1.67*
2026-11-13 16:592033.01.75–7.2%1.70*
2026-11-15 13:392133.30.11.750.4%1.75

* Before 15 Nov outlet nitrate could not be measured (the zinc-reduction kit reads nitrite as nitrate), so removal there assumes none left the bed and is an upper bound. On 30–31 October that assumption needs more electrons than the carbon supplied, which shows some nitrate did pass through then.

Assumptions and limits

  • Feed oxygen 7 mg/L, assumed, not measured. A different value shifts the fitted respiration share but barely moves the dose at the calibration point.
  • The respiration share is fitted on one test. It was close to 100% at 14 mL/day and fell as the bed grew. It is refitted whenever outlet nitrate is tested.
  • Production is the least certain number. Four nitrate tests on a ±3–4 ppm kit; each new test narrows it.
  • Tank nitrate is corrected for nitrite (×1.348), because the kit reads nitrite as nitrate.
  • One well-mixed volume. Two tanks on one sump are treated as one 750 L system.

Same ownership stance as the rest of this site’s build writeups: my own tank, run at my own risk. If any of this is useful for your own build, the same applies to you.